The International Federation of Health Plans (iFHP) today released its2015 Comparative Price Report, detailing its annual survey of medical prices per unit. Designed to showcase the variation in healthcare prices around the world, the report examines the price of medical procedures, tests, scans and treatments in seven countries.
The report undercuts the idea of what’s being played out in the recent Sutter Health case which alleges the health system is overcharging insurers causing medical costs to be pushed downstream to patients. Last Friday, the suit was allowed to seek class-action status. Matthew Cantor, partner and attorney at Constantine Cannon and lead lawyer for the plaintiffs, told Healthcare Dive the plaintiffs allege to have contracts which require health plans to purchase all the hospital services that Sutter provides in Northern California.
Sutter is “leveraging its larger power in those markets to say to these health plans that they have to also purchase Sutter Health hospital services elsewhere and not only do they have to purchase them but they have to purchase those Sutter services at higher, super competitive prices,” Cantor said, adding that this, in turn, raises the costs of medical services to health plans. These higher costs, Cantor said, are then sent downstream to insurance policyholders.
“Competition is not working,” Sackville told Healthcare Dive. “The market’s not working because if it was, no one would get away with charging $17,000 [for a day of hospital care].”
The report put a focus on the lack of provider competition and consolidation. There’s been a fair amount of consolidation in various states and more systems are pursuing the idea of mergers or partnerships. Such activity, in theory, could bring down competition in an area and tick up costs for consumers as hospitals’ market power grows. “Powerful hospital systems have the ability to raise the prices of medical care. Health plans have no alternative but to take these forced, higher costs upon them because [if they refused] then no one would buy their insurance,” Cantor told Healthcare Dive.
HENRY KOTULA 