Fitch: States will take the lead on Medicaid reform despite ACA repeal and replace failure

http://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/fitch-states-will-take-lead-medicaid-reform-despite-aca-repeal-and-replace-failure?mkt_tok=eyJpIjoiWVdGallqTTBZVGRoTVdKaSIsInQiOiI4UXRNZDB6VUZ2MEtTbGhNbm9zZ3dnQys3Z2dkS2VYWDQyZlwvbkxtNEIxRlwvT085a056VlwvbjhweFlxOEFWUktZOGVMeWRTMm5BbCtCaE44T0VlOUNDdkRIQ1ZCRFpBd2NhK1NjZTJOaGFteHJjWEZDOTN5R2pDK3oxb2w4d0xvZSJ9

Some states had already begun negotiations with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services on securing Medicaid waivers, Fitch said.

Despite the Senate’s failure to pass an ACA repeal and replace bill, state governments are moving ahead with their own efforts to revamp Medicaid, especially through waivers, according to a Fitch Ratings report.

Some states had already begun negotiations with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services on securing Medicaid waivers granting them more flexibility. State waiver proposals could affect both Medicaid expansion beneficiaries and the traditional enrollees, the report said.

Arkansas, Indiana and Kentucky have submitted proposals to CMS asking to add work requirements to their Medicaid expansions. Other states including Arizona, Maine, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin are considering work requirements for at least some traditional Medicaid enrollees as well, Fitch said.

Fitch ratings agency said the Trump administration has indicated they are in favor of such measures.

Overall, Fitch said states have indicated their proposed Medicaid changes could reduce costs and also “support key policy goals.”

The states proposing these measures suggested they support “key policy goals” and could yield cost savings. “However, the actual amount of cost savings could be low as some health policy experts have raised questions about the efficacy of such work requirements given characteristics of the current Medicaid population. Adding work requirements could also add to state administrative burdens for oversight of the Medicaid program,” the agency said.

Fitch also projects states will continue to focus on controlling Medicaid spending as they look at their budgets. CMS predicted long-term rises in Medicaid spending due to growth in higher-cost traditional Medicaid-eligible populations, especially the elderly and disabled, and their most recent 10-year forecast for National Health Expenditures showed state and local government Medicaid spending will rise an average of 6.1 percent annually between 2017 and 2025.

“This is far ahead of Fitch’s expectations for national economic growth and state tax revenue growth, signaling continued pressure on states to manage their budgets accordingly,” Fitch said.

Florida Medicaid managed care demonstration gets 5-year extension

http://www.healthcaredive.com/news/florida-medicaid-managed-care-demonstration-gets-5-year-extension/448610/

Dive Brief:

  • CMS approved a five-year extension of Florida’s section 1115 demonstration of a capitated Medicaid managed care program and low-income pool to support uncompensated care.
  • The uncompensated care pool will receive about $1.5 billion annually, based on the most current data on hospitals’ charity care costs, according to an Aug. 3 letter from CMS Administrator Seema Verma to Justin Senior, secretary of the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration.
  • The Managed Medical Assistance (MMA) demonstration, which now runs until June 2022, is the first to include simplified reporting requirements. CMS said it will monitor progress toward state-selected benchmarks and partner with the state to develop a meaningful program evaluation.

Dive Insight:

The modifications are in line with President Donald Trump’s administration’s pledge to reduce what it sees as burdensome or duplicative state reporting activities and with the CMS’ commitment to partner with states to improve their Medicaid programs.

In a March 14 letter, HHS Secretary Tom Price and Verma reminded states they can apply for waivers that would allow for significant changes to their Medicaid programs. States must show their waiver promotes the objectives of the Medicaid program, but HHS has broad authority for approval and Price has indicated he intends to broaden their use.

The CMS had been winding down funding for the Florida program under President Barack Obama’s administration. Officials at the time said the state should expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act to help with uncompensated care costs. They gave Florida $600 million for the final year of the program, far less than the about $2 billion requested.

The amount of funding now being provided offers a pretty clear indication the CMS under Trump thinks Florida is on the right track without expansion.

More than 30 states currently have waivers. Alabama received CMS approval in February for a section 1115 demonstration waiver to shift a majority of its Medicaid beneficiaries into regional care organizations, akin to accountable care organizations. While there are other states using this strategy, Alabama is unique in that it’s being administered by provider-run nonprofit organizations rather than a major insurer.

Patient advocacy groups have voiced alarm at potential steep cuts to Medicaid. Trump’s proposed $4.1 trillion budget would slash $610 billion from Medicaid plus 20% of funding for the Children’s Health Insurance Program. Robert Greenstein, president of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, said Trump’s budget would increase the number of uninsured and narrow Medicaid benefits and eligibility. This would lead to higher uncompensated care costs for hospitals.

GOP states move to cut Medicaid

GOP states move to cut Medicaid

GOP states move to cut Medicaid

Republican governors are working with the Trump administration to do something Congress couldn’t accomplish: fundamentally alter their state Medicaid programs.

At least six states with GOP governors— Arkansas, Kentucky, Arizona, Maine, Wisconsin and Indiana — have already drafted plans meant to introduce new rules people would have to meet to be eligible for Medicaid, which provides healthcare to low-income Americans and those with certain disabilities.

Some want to add work requirements or introduce drug testing for recipients. Others want to raise premium prices.

The Trump administration has to approve the plans. Some approvals could come in weeks.

Critics say the proposed changes will leave fewer people on Medicaid and hurt the poor and vulnerable.

“There are limits on what’s allowable, and tying eligibility to work or drug testing or some of these other things is not consistent with what should be allowed,” said Judith Solomon, vice president for health policy at the liberal-leaning Centers on Budget and Policy Priorities.

“That said, we know we now have an administration that likely thinks differently, and we could see some changes in that regard,” she said.

Proponents argue the changes, which would waive federal requirements under Medicaid, are an important tool in trimming the fast-rising costs of the program.

They say Medicaid recipients should have some “skin in the game” — an incentive to transition from government support to full-time employment.

“Medicaid is Pac-Manning state budgets right now. It’s taking money away from education, transportation, in expansion and non-expansion states alike. It is eating their budgets,” said Josh Archambault, a senior fellow at the conservative Foundation for Government Accountability.

In the past, waivers have been granted to test new ways of delivering care and expanding Medicaid coverage. The only real requirements are that the waivers be budget neutral and promote the objectives of the Medicaid program.

Health and Human Services Secretary Tom Price, a former Republican congressman from Georgia and a vocal ObamaCare critic, has enormous flexibility in deciding what that means.

In March, Price and Seema Verma, who helms the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, sent a letter to governors saying the administration would allow work requirements, larger premiums and other waiver provisions.

It was a dramatic departure from the Obama administration and “an open invitation” for states, said Robin Rudowitz, associate director for the Kaiser Family Foundation’s Program on Medicaid and the Uninsured.

“By and large, Obama let states use waivers to expand the number of people in the Medicaid program,” Archambault said.

The Trump administration seems poised to do the opposite.

Critics say the proposed requirements go beyond the authority of the executive branch, but Archambault said the statute on what’s allowed is extremely broad, meaning the administration has the authority to approve most, if not all of the proposals.

Republicans in Congress have been deeply divided over Medicaid, with conservatives seeking to cut spending on the program but centrists from states where it was expanded under ObamaCare pushing back.

The House and Senate’s ObamaCare repeal bills sought to drastically cut back Medicaid spending by capping federal financing and ending ObamaCare’s enhanced federal funding for coverage expansion. The bills also would have given states the option of imposing work requirements.

Medicaid waivers can’t change the program’s financing the way a federal law could, but several state waivers filed months ago include a work requirement as a way to trim spending.

Work requirements “will have the result of cutting state Medicaid costs because fewer people will be on Medicaid,” said Deborah Bachrach, a partner at Manatt Health and former Medicaid director of New York.

To date, no state has received an approval for a waiver requiring people to work to be eligible for Medicaid. If the Trump administration approves of one, most experts think other states will get similar requirements approved quickly.

“If and when Kentucky and Arizona get approval … you’ll see a bunch of other Republican states copycat,” Archambault said.

Other changes, if approved, include lowering the eligibility levels for coverage and a time limit for being on Medicaid.

Arkansas recently filed a waiver request to lower the Medicaid eligibility level while still receiving extra federal money as a Medicaid expansion state. It’s the first state to make such a request of the Trump administration; some states tried similar requests during the Obama administration and were denied.

Wisconsin would like to screen all and test some applicants for drugs. Those who test positive for drugs would be required to receive treatment; those who refuse to be screened or take a test would be ineligible for Medicaid benefits.

The state also wants to impose a 48-month limit on Medicaid eligibility, unless the person is working.

“My biggest concern is that the state is going to create a lot of new red tape and expense that is going to suppress Medicaid participation and increase total healthcare costs by putting greater reliance on hospital and emergency departments,” Jon Peacock, research director for Wisconsin-based Kids Forward, said.

Experts warn certain controversial provisions, if implemented, could be targets for lawsuits.

“Some of these waivers are pushing the boundaries of what has been approved before, and that could lead to potential litigation,” Rudowitz said.

What’s the Near-Term Outlook for the Affordable Care Act?

http://www.kff.org/health-reform/issue-brief/whats-the-near-term-outlook-for-the-affordable-care-act/?utm_campaign=KFF-2017-August-Health-Reform-Outlook-ACA&utm_medium=email&_hsenc=p2ANqtz–oP5wlywrzGCg7hZVAatEjF0shnUXWvPMPB7MBQfAJJXiDqeMCZIkw7rhXhhVQ7bv4RTl4IFWk3zbvJFTnYv730hVqBQ&_hsmi=54950542&utm_content=54950542&utm_source=hs_email&hsCtaTracking=b35f36e5-60c0-4e14-ba27-3e14c4025b79%7Cf0a0cb87-2715-4168-b499-2000076067bf

If Congress abandons efforts to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act (ACA), President Trump has said he would “let Obamacare fail.” This Q&A examines what could happen if the Affordable Care Act, also called “Obamacare,” remains the law and what it might mean to let Obamacare fail.

Is Obamacare failing?

The Affordable Care Act was a major piece of legislation that affects virtually all payers in the U.S. health system, including Medicaid, Medicare, employer-sponsored insurance, and coverage people buy on their own. One of the biggest changes under the health reform law was the expansion of the Medicaid program, which now covers nearly 75 million people, about 14 million of whom are signed up under the expansion. Most Americans, including most Republicans, believe the Medicaid program is working well.

When people talk about the idea of the ACA failing, they are usually referring to the exchange markets, also called Marketplaces. These markets, which first opened in 2014, are part of the broader individual insurance market where just 5-7% of the U.S. population gets their insurance. People who get insurance from other sources like their work or Medicaid are not directly affected by what happens in the individual insurance market.

The exchange markets have not been without problems: There have been some notable exits by insurance companies and premium increases going into 2017, and in the early years of the exchanges, insurers were losing money. The structure of the ACA’s premium subsidies – which rise along with premiums and cap what consumers have to pay for a benchmark plans a percentage of their income – prevents the market from deteriorating into a “death spiral.” However, premiums could become unaffordable in some parts of the country for people with incomes in excess of 400% of the poverty level, who are ineligible for premium assistance.

Insurer participation in this market has received a great deal of attention, as about 1 in 3 counties – primarily rural areas – have only one insurer on exchange. Rural counties have historically had limited competition even before the ACA, but data now available because of the Affordable Care Act brings the urban/rural divide into sharper focus. On average at the state level, competition in the individual market has been relatively stable – neither improving nor worsening.

Premiums in the reformed individual market started out relatively low and remained low in the first few years – about 12% lower than the Congressional Budget Office had projected as of 2016 –before increasing more rapidly in 2017. Most (83%) of the 12 million people buying their own coverage on the exchange receive subsidies and therefore are not as affected by the premium increases, but many of the approximately 9 million people buying off-exchange may have difficulty affording coverage, despite having higher incomes. As might be expected, after taking into account financial assistance and protections for people with pre-existing conditions, some people ended up paying more and others paying less than they did before the ACA. Our early polling in this market found that people in this market were nearly evenly split between paying more and paying less. About 3 millionpeople who remain uninsured are not eligible for assistance or employer coverage and many of them may be going without coverage due to costs.

Our recent analysis of first quarter 2017 insurer financial results finds that the market is not showing signs of collapse. Rather, insurers are on track to be profitable and the market appears to be stabilizing in the country overall. In other words, those premium increases going into 2017 may have been enough to make the market stable without discouraging too many healthy people from signing up. However, there are still markets – particularly rural ones – that are fragile.

Even Without Congress, Trump Can Still Cut Medicaid Enrollment

http://khn.org/news/even-without-congress-trump-can-still-cut-medicaid-enrollment/?utm_campaign=KHN%3A%20First%20Edition&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=54783651&_hsenc=p2ANqtz–aF5XHjpe0dFB9W_VN-Bkj8-2569l2BxRKp3AQp2hCbyUtD81HicWsZhf1UY4sabATUpSmne463O3X5YHXK3CHKpfQQA&_hsmi=54783651

After the Senate fell short in its effort to repeal the Affordable Care Act, the Trump administration is poised to use its regulatory powers to accomplish what lawmakers could not: shrink Medicaid.

President Donald Trump’s top health officials could engineer lower enrollment in the state-federal health insurance program by approving applications from several GOP-controlled states eager to control fast-rising Medicaid budgets.

Indiana, Arkansas, Kentucky, Arizona and Wisconsin are seeking the administration’s permission to require adult enrollees to work, submit to drug testing and demand that some of their poorest recipients pay monthly premiums or get barred from the program.

Maine plans to apply Tuesday. Other states would likely follow if the first ones get the go-ahead.

Josh Archambault, senior fellow for the conservative Foundation for Government Accountability, said absent congressional action on the health bill “the administration may be even more proactive in engaging with states on waivers outside of those that are already planning to do so.”

The hope, he added, is that fewer individuals will be on the program as states figure out ways “to transition able-bodied enrollees into new jobs, or higher-paying jobs.” States need to shore up the program to be able to keep meeting demands for the “truly needy,” such as children and the disabled, he added.

To Medicaid’s staunchest supporters and most vocal critics alike, the waiver requests are a way to rein in the $500 billion program that has undergone unprecedented growth the past four years and now covers 75 million people.

Waivers have often been granted in the past to broaden coverage and test new ways to deliver Medicaid care, such as through private managed-care organizations.

But critics of the new requests, which could be approved within weeks, said they could hurt those who are most in need.

The National Health Law Program “is assessing the legality of work requirements and drug testing and all avenues for challenging them, including litigation,” said Jane Perkins, the group’s legal director.

The administration has already said it favors work requirements and in March invited states to suggest new ideas.

Before taking the top job at the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Seema Verma was the architect of a Kentucky waiver request submitted last year.

Not all states are expected to seek waivers, because Medicaid enjoys wide political support in many states, particularly in the Northeast and West.

Medicaid, the nation’s largest health insurance program, has seen enrollment soar by 17 million since 2014, when Obamacare gave states more federal funding to expand coverage for adults. It’s typically states’ second-largest expense after education.

This year, Senate and House bills tried to cap federal funding to states for the first time. Since the program began in 1965, federal Medicaid funding to states has been open-ended.

Health experts say allowing the waiver requests goes beyond the executive branch’s authority to change the program without approval from Congress.

“The point of these waivers is not for states to remake the program whole-cloth on a large-scale basis,” said Sara Rosenbaum, a health policy expert at George Washington University who chairs a Medicaid group that advises Congress.

Rosenbaum noted that states received waivers for different purposes under the Obama administration.

In Iowa, state officials won the authority to limit non-emergency transportation. Indiana received approval to charge premiums and lock out enrollees with incomes above the federal poverty level if they fell behind on paying premiums.

“Now there is concern these more extreme measures would hurt enrollees’ access to care,” Rosenbaum said.

Three states seeking waivers today are home to three key GOP players in the Senate health debate: Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (Kentucky), Sen. John McCain (Arizona) and Vice President Mike Pence (Indiana).

If states add premiums, as well as work and drug testing requirements, the result would be fewer people enrolling and staying in Medicaid, said David Machledt, senior policy analyst for the National Health Law Program.

“How does that serve the purpose of the Medicaid program and what are the limits of CMS waiver authority?” he asked.

Wisconsin, where Republican Gov. Scott Walker wants his state to become the first to require some Medicaid enrollees to undergo drug testing, is a prime waiver candidate.

State officials stress the effort is not to deter drug users from the program but to help provide treatment for drug users.

Wisconsin is also one of five states seeking a waiver to add a work requirement. People could meet the mandate through volunteering, job training or caring for an elderly relative.

In addition, Wisconsin wants to limit enrollees’ Medicaid benefits to 48 consecutive months, unless the beneficiary is working.

Enrollees with incomes from 50 percent to 100 percent of the federal poverty level, or between $6,030 and$12,060, would have to pay an $8 monthly premium.

All of these rules would apply to about 12 percent of people currently enrolled in Medicaid — adults who are not disabled and don’t have dependent children.

Wisconsin Medicaid Director Michael Heifetz said the main goal of the proposed changes is not to shrink the size of Medicaid but to get people into the workforce.

“The proposal is not designed to have folks leave the program except for positive reasons,” he said.

If the waiver is approved, the state anticipates annual savings of nearly $50 million and a drop in enrollment of 5,102 over five years.

Wisconsin now spends $7 billion on Medicaid and has 1.2 million recipients.

Asked why childless adults — not parents — are the focus of the waivers, Heifetz said Wisconsin wanted to test the provisions on a smaller population first and focus on adults who should be able to find work.

But the Wisconsin effort has sparked broad outrage from hospitals, doctors and advocates for people with disabilities.

The Wisconsin Council of Churches said the state would be punishing the poor with its waivers — and undermining the vitality of communities.

“We are concerned the proposed changes to the program will be detrimental for the health of our most vulnerable neighbors … and undermine the social fabric and vitality of our state,” said Peter Bakken, public policy coordinator for the group in Sun Prairie, a suburb of Madison.

Graham, Trump discuss alternate ObamaCare repeal bill

Graham, Trump discuss alternate ObamaCare repeal bill

Image result for block grant medicaid

Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) met with President Trump Friday at the White House about the senator’s ObamaCare replacement proposal.

The meeting comes as some Republicans are pushing to keep alive their effort to repeal and replace ObamaCare despite the failed vote in the Senate early Friday morning.

Graham has pitched his bill as a better alternative to ObamaCare than GOP leaders’ plans. His measure, also backed by Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-La.), would convert money currently being spent on providing ObamaCare coverage into a block grant to states. States could then choose how to spend the funds.

“I had a great meeting with the President and know he remains fully committed to repealing and replacing Obamacare,” Graham said in a statement Friday afternoon.

“President Trump was optimistic about the Graham-Cassidy-Heller proposal. I will continue to work with President Trump and his team to move the idea forward.”

Graham has also spoken with House Freedom Caucus Chairman Mark Meadows (R-N.C.) about the idea, Graham spokesman Kevin Bishop said.

Meadows is also pushing to keep alive the repeal effort and said he had been talking to multiple senators.

“I just think that we’ve got to regroup and continue to stay involved and find something that has 51 votes in the Senate that we can make work,” Meadows told reporters Friday.

Continued efforts to replace the healthcare law face a steep path, though. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) said after the failed vote early Friday on a slimmed-down repeal bill that “it is time to move on.”

Republicans have been unable to find 51 votes to pass a plan through the Senate. Other Republicans have started talking about a bipartisan approach.

Graham has expressed hope that Democrats could sign on to his proposal, but so far none have.

Liberal experts have criticized his plan. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities wrote that the proposal would lead to “drastic cuts” in both Medicaid and subsidies for private insurance, because the amount of the block grants to states would be below ObamaCare spending levels.

How Many People Across America Are at Risk of Losing Their Health Insurance?

Image result for How Many People Across America Are at Risk of Losing Their Health Insurance?

Between 2010 and 2015, more than 19 million people in the United States gained health insurance, mostly through key provisions under the Affordable Care Act, according to an analysis by the Urban Institute.

Many of the newly insured were not poor enough to qualify for Medicaid but too poor to buy their own coverage. Others were shut out because of pre-existing conditions.

These groups and others make up the millions that the Congressional Budget Office says could lose their coverage under the Republican plans to repeal and possibly replace the Affordable Care Act.

“All of the elements that enabled more people to get insurance under Obamacare — protections for pre-existing conditions, the expansion of Medicaid and subsidies to make insurance more affordable — are potentially at risk under the various options the Senate is debating,” said Larry Levitt, a policy expert at the Kaiser Family Foundation.

Under six Republican proposals that the Congressional Budget Office had analyzed, the number of uninsured in America would increase by 22 million to 32 million people in 10 years — essentially erasing much of the gains made under the Affordable Care Act. A C.B.O. analysis released Wednesday night showed that a “skinny” repeal measurebeing floated by lawmakers would increase the number by 16 million in 10 years.

“It’s a dramatic understatement to say there’s uncertainty about where this debate will end up,” Mr. Levitt said.

Would your plan cover John McCain’s treatment?

https://www.healthinsurance.org/blog/2017/07/25/would-your-plan-cover-john-mccains-treatment/

Image result for adequate health insurance coverage

The Arizona Senator’s health plan will ensure top-notch glioblastoma treatment, but how would Americans with other health coverage fare?

Last week, we heard the sad news that Senator John McCain has been diagnosed with glioblastoma. McCain had surgery at Phoenix’s Mayo Clinic in mid-July, and it’s expected that he’ll also receive chemotherapy and radiation, along with other potential treatments. Senator McCain has proven time and again that he’s tough as nails, and appears to be facing this latest battle head-on. One thing that he likely has on his side is top-notch health insurance.

McCain is 80, which means he’s presumably been on Medicare for 15 years. Currently serving federal lawmakers are able to obtain employer-subsidized coverage in the Washington DC small-business exchange, and they can have this coverage in addition to Medicare.

How good is McCain’s coverage?

McCain hasn’t said publicly exactly what insurance he has, and his office has not responded to my inquiry. But the most likely scenario is that he has Medicare plus employer-sponsored coverage through the DC exchange – a very comprehensive benefits package.

There are certainly lots of other people who have similar coverage arrangements – either because they’re still working after turning 65, like McCain, or because they receive generous retiree health benefits that supplement their Medicare coverage. For those who don’t, there are private Medicare supplements available that cover virtually all of the out-of-pocket costs associated with Medicare.

But health coverage in the United States is a bit of a mixed bag, with some people having much better coverage than others. A serious illness tends to shine a spotlight on the flaws that exist in some health plans, so let’s take a look at how the average American facing a glioblastoma diagnosis would fare under various health plans.

Employer-sponsored health insurance

Most employer-sponsored health insurance plans provide pretty solid health coverage. According to a 2016 Kaiser Family Foundation analysis, the average deductible for covered workers was about $1,500, and that doesn’t count the 17 percent of covered workers whose plans had no deductible at all.

In addition, the average employer paid more than two-thirds of the total premiums. And the tax exclusion of employer-sponsored insurance premiums amounts to a subsidy that cost the federal government $250 billion in fiscal year 2016.

However, employer-sponsored health insurance is, by definition, linked to employment. A person going through a serious illness like glioblastoma might not be able to continue working, depending on the specifics of the treatment.

As long as the employer has at least 20 employees, the employee will be able to continue the coverage under COBRA for 18 months, even if he or she is unable to work. But COBRA is expensive, as the employer contribution to the premiums and the tax exclusion of the premiums are eliminated. (COBRA premiums are counted as a medical expense for the purpose of itemized medical deductions, but only expenses that exceed 10 percent of your income can be deducted this way.)

Although most employer-sponsored plans provide good coverage, that’s due in part to the ACA. It was not uncommon – particularly in low-wage, high turnover industries – for employers to offer “mini-meds” before the ACA, with exceedingly low benefit caps. (The ACA’s ban on lifetime and annual benefit limits means that these plans are no longer offered to employees.)

A mini-med with a $2,000 or $5,000 annual benefit maximum would not have done much in the face of glioblastoma. Vox reported that just the initial craniotomy to remove a blood clot above Senator McCain’s eye would likely have been billed at more than $76,000. And that was before the cancer diagnosis.

ACA-compliant individual market coverage

The pre-ACA individual market included plenty of solid plans. But dubious coverage also abounded, and regulations varied considerably from one state to another.

The ACA imposed a bevy of regulations on the individual health insurance market, bringing all new (as of 2014) plans up at least a basic minimum standard. Individual major medical coverage can no longer be sold without the ACA’s essential health benefits.

And for those benefits, insurers cannot limit how much they’ll pay during a year or over the course of an insured’s lifetime. (Sadly, another Arizona resident with cancer, Arijit Guha, died in 2013 at age 32. Guha’s health insurance plan had a $300,000 lifetime cap – which is no longer allowed, thanks to the ACA – and his treatment, including chemotherapy that cost $11,000 per session, quickly exceeded that limit.)

Individual-market plans also cannot discriminate against people with pre-existing conditions, either by charging them higher prices or declining their applications (both of those were standard practice in nearly every state prior to 2014). Notably, Senator McCain has a history of melanoma, which would have virtually guaranteed a declined application in the individual market pre-ACA if he had been in need of non-group coverage for some reason.

A person with ACA-compliant individual market coverage would have solid coverage for glioblastoma. The maximum out-of-pocket costs during 2017 would be $7,150, although most plans have out-of-pocket maximums below that threshold. And 57 percent of people who enrolled through the exchanges in 2017 have cost-sharing subsidies, which further reduce the out-of-pocket costs.

The American Cancer Society explains in more detail how the ACA improves access to care for people with cancer. But the short story is that a person facing glioblastoma with a 2017 individual health insurance policy has a much more secure financial safety net than someone with the same diagnosis a decade ago.

Medicaid

Medicaid provides comprehensive coverage. Although the benefits available under traditional Medicaid vary from one state to another, Medicaid expansion coverage is required to include the ACA’s essential health benefits. (The Senate’s Better Care Reconciliation Act – BCRA – would eliminate this requirement after 2019.)

Medicaid has minimal cost-sharing, limited to no more than 5 percent of a family’s annual income.

It’s true that compared with private health insurance and Medicare, fewer medical providers accept Medicaid. But the majority do work with Medicaid. (According to a Kaiser Family Foundation analysis, about 69 percent of office-based physicians accept new Medicaid patients, while about 85 percent accept new privately-insured patients.)

Short-term health insurance

The ACA implemented regulations that apply to virtually all types of health insurance. But some plans are not regulated by the law, including short-term health insurance.

As evidenced by the name, short-term plans are limited in their duration. As of 2017, a short-term plan can last no more than three months, although people who remain healthy can purchase a second short-term plan after the first one ends.

Short-term plans do not cover pre-existing conditions. So if you were to be diagnosed with glioblastoma while covered under a short-term plan, the first thing the insurer would do is go back through your medical records to make sure that you didn’t have any symptoms prior to enrolling in the plan.

Assuming you were healthy before you enrolled, your short-term plan would start to cover your treatments. But you would be facing a looming and inflexible coverage termination date, along with annual and lifetime benefit maximums. Short-term plans vary considerably in quality – some have lifetime benefit maximums of $250,000 or less, while others provide benefits well in excess of a million dollars. In the case of a glioblastoma diagnosis, coverage would end when the policy reached its predetermined end date, or when you hit your benefit maximum – whichever happened first.

Either way, you’d want to hope that you had other coverage already lined up and ready to go at that point. The cancer diagnosis would make it impossible to obtain another short-term policy.

And since a short-term plan is not considered minimum essential coverage, the termination of the short-term policy would not trigger a special enrollment period for individual or employer-sponsored insurance. You would still be able to enroll in a regular individual-market plan, or an employer plan if you’re eligible for one, during regular annual open enrollment. But you might experience a significant gap in coverage, which can be disastrous in the middle of cancer treatment.

A limited-benefit plan

Limited-benefit plans are another category of coverage that’s not regulated by the ACA (despite attempts by the Obama Administration to place some regulations on certain types of fixed indemnity coverage).

Fixed indemnity means that the plan pays a specific dollar amount if the insured has a covered claim. For example, the plan might pay $1,000 per day for hospitalization, or $50 for a doctor visit. There’s no cap on how much the patient has to pay, and these plans often have very low annual and lifetime benefit limits.

So imagine a plan that will pay $2,000 per day for hospitalization, for up to 25 days. It will also pay $2,500 for an outpatient surgical procedure and $2,500 for an inpatient surgical procedure. And it will pay $625 for anesthesia, but it does not cover prescriptions (these numbers are from a real plan currently available in the limited benefit market).

Remember that McCain’s craniotomy – before the glioblastoma was even diagnosed – likely cost $70,000. He was home very soon after the surgery, so if he was hospitalized at all, it wasn’t more than a day or two. A limited benefit plan like the one described above would have paid $2,000 for each day in the hospital (which amounts to zero dollars if the procedure didn’t result in an inpatient stay), $2,500 for the surgery, and $625 for the anesthesia. That would leave a sizeable chunk of the $70,000 bill as the patient’s responsibility.

And all of that is before the treatment for the glioblastoma even begins.

A Cruz Amendment plan

In mid-July, Senator Ted Cruz introduced an amendment to the BCRA aimed at reducing regulations on health insurance plans. The Cruz Amendment, if included in the BCRA, would allow insurers to offer non-ACA-compliant plans as long as they also offered at least one Silver plan, one Gold plan, and one plan that complies with the BCRA’s benchmark standards (58 percent actuarial value).

The non-compliant plans would likely range from decent to terrible, since they would have wide latitude in terms of the consumer protections they’d be able to waive. Essentially, it would be a return to the pre-ACA days when there was more of an “anything goes” approach to health insurance. Plans would be available without essential health benefits, would not have to cover pre-existing conditions, and could be offered with higher out-of-pocket limits than ACA compliant plans.

These plans would likely appeal to healthy people, as they would be less expensive than ACA compliant plans. But a person who seems perfectly healthy can be diagnosed with glioblastoma, at which point the holes in the coverage become glaringly apparent.

What about those who lack McCain’s coverage

In glioblastoma, Senator McCain is facing a fierce battle, and our hearts go out to him and his family. But thanks to McCain’s health coverage, he won’t have to worry about how to pay for his treatment. I’m glad he has that health coverage.

Senator McCain is not alone in his battle. There are more than 12,000 Americans who will be diagnosed with glioblastoma this year. Unfortunately, many of them do not have the level of health coverage that McCain has. Even with the best health insurance, the diagnosis plunges each family into an immensely challenging situation. With lesser – or no – coverage, the challenge becomes even more insurmountable.

Nobody deserves cancer. And nobody deserves to have to fight cancer with less-than-adequate health insurance. With our current medical know-how, we can’t keep everyone from getting cancer. But we can make sure that as many people as possible are covered by high-quality health insurance. We owe it to all the lesser-known John McCains out there to work towards that goal.

That means pushing back against any sort of “reform” that would result in fewer people with insurance. It also means rejecting proposals that would allow junk insurance plans to flood the market, lulling consumers into a false sense of security – until they’re diagnosed with brain cancer.

 

The Medicaid Fund: Beware of Gifts

http://thenews.pl/1/11/Artykul/317380,Poland-to-open-new-museum-at-German-Nazi-Treblinka-death-camp

Image result for medicaid

Press reports have suggested that to get the Affordable Care Act repeal-and-replace effort back on track, Senate leaders are now offering, as part of their Better Care Reconciliation Act (BCRA), a $200 billion fund to help states partially offset the nearly $800 billion dollars in lost federal Medicaid funding they would face over the next decade if BCRA became law. This fund, to be administered by the U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), would apparently be used to help low-income people transition from Medicaid to private insurance.

The offer, if accurate, still amounts to a 75 percent reduction in funding. So the fund does little to address the human and financial consequences of BCRA’s original Medicaid cuts. It’s also unclear how it would work or affect the private insurance market. Furthermore, it’s uncertain whether the Senate parliamentarian would allow a new program. Even if permitted under the strict rules governing the Senate reconciliation process, the program would encounter major legal and operational hurdles in implementation, as well as questions about the lack of public accountability for drawing on the money. It is also worth noting that this type of strategy, in which the HHS secretary is given vast powers over how to allocate funds under the loose rubric of “transition,” may itself raise questions about whether Congress simply has thrown a handful of dollars at the problem, and coupled these dollars with an extraordinary delegation of its constitutional legislative powers to the executive branch.

Today, if a state chooses to insure a Medicaid-eligible population, the federal government will pay a percentage of actual costs. Like insurance generally, these costs can vary by the type of population insured (healthy people versus those who are sick), the amount and intensity of services furnished, and the prices paid. In any year, and in any state, costs vary enormously, a fact driven home by the economic fallout from the opioid epidemic or the Zika virus. The federal Medicaid contribution to state programs ranges from 50 percent to about 75 percent, with higher contributions for low-income adults covered under the ACA’s Medicaid expansion. Equally importantly, there is real accountability in federal Medicaid payments spent to insure people — we know how many people are covered and what services are paid for.

Over the past several weeks, a blizzard of analyses and reports has made clear just how essential Medicaid is to states, their populations, their economies, and their ability to maintain operational health care systems for everyone. Receiving 25 cents on the dollar in lieu of guaranteed Medicaid financing would be little consolation; this is particularly true since presumably, like other special payments to states under the bill, the fund can be expected to be time-limited, after which more action from Congress would be needed to extend its life.

Let’s imagine that this fund becomes law, with details to be hashed out later. A host of questions would arise, all of which would need to be translated into complex and contentious regulations, issued following a lengthy rulemaking process. For example, will normal federal matching rules apply when states draw on this fund, or will states have to put up more funding or perhaps none at all? What types of costs will be recognized as eligible for fund payments? Will all states be able to participate or just those losing expansion funding? Will states be permitted to help only selected Medicaid expansion beneficiaries losing coverage? Although the fund is billed as transitional assistance for beneficiaries, would this include direct payments to providers to allow for continuity of care? Under laws that govern agency policymaking and spending decisions such as when, where, and how to spend $200 billion, these questions and many more would need to move a formal policy development process. The HHS secretary cannot simply dole out unstructured funding that could be used for purposes only tangentially related to transitions.

No vague promises or pennies-on-the-dollar slush fund can take the place of what Medicaid does for people and for states. Nor can it compensate for the consequences of ending the compact on which Medicaid has rested for over 50 years.

State-by-State Estimates of Reductions in Federal Medicaid Funding

Better Care Reconciliation Act (BCRA): State-by-State Estimates of Reductions in Federal Medicaid Funding – Issue Brief

Medicaid Changes under the BCRA and Possible State Responses

Our analysis examines the changes in the BCRA that would phase out the enhanced matching rate for the ACA Medicaid expansion and limit federal Medicaid spending to a capped amount per enrollee for five eligibility groups (expansion adults, other adults, children, the elderly and people with disabilities). First, under the BCRA, for states that adopted the expansion as of March 1, 2017, the enhanced federal match would phase out from 90% in 2020 to 85% in 2021, 80% in 2022, 75% in 2023 and then to the regular state match rate in 2024 and beyond. This phase out lowers federal Medicaid spending relative to current law, under which federal financing for the expansion population would remain at 90% in 2020 and in subsequent years.

Second, under the BCRA, federal Medicaid spending for most enrollees would be limited to a set amount per enrollee. To establish these limits, states would use data from FY 2014-2016 to develop base year per enrollee spending that would be inflated to 2019 based on the medical component of the consumer price index (CPI-M). Beginning in 2020, federal spending would be limited to the federal share of spending based on per enrollee amounts calculated by inflating the base year spending by CPI-M for children and adults and CPI-M plus one percentage point for the elderly and disabled. Beginning in 2025, all per enrollee limits would be increased by general inflation (CPI-U). Certain spending and populations would be excluded from the per enrollee caps, including enrollees who do not receive the full scope of Medicaid benefits.

States could respond to these changes in federal policy in several ways. We examine changes in federal Medicaid spending under two possible scenarios of state responses: (1) All states, both expansion states and non-expansion states, fill gaps in the loss of federal funding and maintain coverage, including the ACA Medicaid expansion coverage, and (2) states that expanded Medicaid under the ACA fully drop their expansions but maintain spending and coverage for other groups, resulting in declines in both federal and state spending. In the second scenario, we model the loss of federal dollars that the state would have received had it fully maintained its expansion.