Repealing the Affordable Care Act

https://www.brookings.edu/blog/unpacked/2017/03/08/repealing-the-affordable-care-act/?utm_campaign=Economic%20Studies&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=45259936

Image result for brookings institute

THE ISSUE: If Congress rejects the new House Republican-backed replacement for the Affordable Care Act (ACA), the full repeal long advocated for by many Republicans could be their next option.

A straight ACA repeal would leave an estimated 20+ million people without health coverage.

THE THINGS YOU NEED TO KNOW

  • Republicans have long advocated for repealing the ACA and if their new replacement isn’t approved, that plan could soon be put into motion.
  • The ACA provides coverage, and subsidies towards coverage, to people who previously couldn’t get health insurance through the individual market.
  • A straight ACA repeal would leave an estimated 20+ million people without health coverage.
  • If the ACA is repealed, many lower-income Americans (earning a maximum family income of about $33,000) participating in Medicaid, which was expanded under the ACA, would lose health coverage.
  • Many individuals with pre-existing medical conditions, previously unable to get health insurance, would also lose coverage.
  • The ACA also benefits health insurance industry by stabilizing coverage, and provides assurance to state hospitals that patients have coverage of some kind.
  • It is incumbent upon Republicans to provide a clear plan and implement it quickly in order to stabilize the markets and assure Americans that whatever replaces the ACA will be at least as good and at least as affordable as their current plans.
  • Polling on repeal shows that people are unhappy with the ACA, but not with their coverage. They most frequently criticizes the cost and the availability of coverage.
  • Republicans are faced with a challenge: Americans don’t just want repeal, they want a replacement that is comprehensive and affordable.

CBO: Republican healthcare bill would cover millions fewer than ACA but reduce federal deficit

http://www.fiercehealthcare.com/aca/cbo-republican-healthcare-bill-would-cover-millions-fewer-than-aca-but-reduce-federal-deficit?mkt_tok=eyJpIjoiTW1OaFl6TXlZVFF6WldKayIsInQiOiI3eHNMN1ZraGpJWHJ0eUFFRmdzaDRjVFVsOXBpV0VKVzdtWlU1UmxTbVZWRkpnMDhEN0Rrb3cyZlwvM0NmZnFJMXZTOG1KYXlLRHc0YWNUQzA3MmhpOVNQRFN4WmNsNUZVQmNQTGdPWE5UNUczUGppRUFGZ2dwelltaldGXC9IM3pWIn0%3D&mrkid=959610&utm_medium=nl&utm_source=internal

capitol

The Congressional Budget Office on Monday released its highly anticipated score of House Republicans’ healthcare bill, finding that it would increase the number of uninsured individuals by millions, but also lower individual market premiums in the long run and decrease the federal deficit.

Congress uses the CBO’s cost estimates to evaluate the effects of any major legislation, and policymakers were particularly eager to get its estimate for the American Health Care Act given the high political stakes associated with the bill.

Here’s a brief rundown of the CBO’s estimates (PDF):

  • In 2018, 14 million more people would be uninsured under the GOP bill than under the Affordable Care Act—mostly due to the repeal of the individual mandate penalties. By 2026, that number would swell to 24 million because of changes to subsidies in the individual market and in the Medicaid program.
  • Relative to projections for the ACA, the Republicans’ bill would lead to higher average premiums in the individual market before 2020—15% in 2018 and 20% in 2019—and lower average premiums after that. The CBO notes, though, that premium changes under the new proposal would differ “significantly” for people of different ages, given the bill’s provision that allows insurers to charge older customers up to five times more for coverage.
  • Enacting the legislation would reduce federal deficits by $337 billion from 2017 to 2026, with the largest savings coming from reductions in Medicaid spending and eliminating the ACA’s subsidies for individual market customers. The largest costs, on the other hand, would come from the bill’s elimination of many of the ACA’s taxes and its creation of a new tax credit for health insurance.
  • The CBO estimates that the individual market would probably be stable in most areas under either the ACA or the AHCA. While tax credits under the newly proposed bill would be less generous than the ACA’s subsidies, other changes such as grants to states from the Patient and State Stability Fund would lower average premiums enough “to attract a sufficient number of relatively healthy people to stabilize the market,” the agency said.

Before the score emerged, the Trump administration had already cast doubt on the merits of the CBO’s projections. White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer pointed out during a press briefing Monday that the agency had originally projected 24 million people would be enrolled through the Affordable Care Act exchanges as of 2016, but the number ended up being only about 10.4 million.

“The CBO was off by more than half last time,” he said.

Later, he acknowledged that some senators are likely to look at the CBO’s score when evaluating the American Health Care Act, and it’s important to remind them of the agency’s past track record.

Previously, The Commonwealth Fund issued an analysis that sought to dispel such criticism of the agency’s estimates about the ACA. It concluded that while the CBO overestimated marketplace enrollment and costs and underestimated Medicaid enrollment, overall its projections were “reasonably accurate,” and closer to realized experience than the estimates of many other prominent forecasters.

 

CBO report predicts 24 million would lose coverage by 2026 under American Health Care Act

http://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/cbo-report-predicts-24-million-would-lose-coverage-2026-under-american-health-care-act

Image result for CBO report predicts 24 million would lose coverage by 2026 under American Health Care Act

An estimated 14 million people would lose coverage under the American Health Care Act, a number that would rise to 24 million by 2026, according to a Congressional Budget Officer report released Monday afternoon.

Most of the initial loss would be due to repeal of the federal mandate for individuals to buy coverage, due to lack of a financial penalty and higher premiums.

Uninsured numbers would rise due to the bill’s repeal of Medicaid expansion. Some states would discontinue the expansion. Also per beneficiary spending caps would affect coverage, the CBO said.

Due to a lack of subsidies for insurance purchased in the nongroup market and to the Medicaid program, the increase in the number of uninsured people relative would rise to 21 million in 2020 and then to 24 million in 2026, the CBO said.

“In 2026, an estimated 52 million people would be uninsured, compared with 28 million who would lack insurance that year under current law,” the CBO said.

Premiums are expected to rise 15 to 20 percent in 2018 and 2019.

Older Americans would pay five times the amount on their premiums as compared to younger enrollees.

 

Federalism and the End of American Healthcare Act

http://www.yalelawjournal.org/forum/federalism-and-the-end-of-obamacare

Federalism and the American Health Care Act

Image result for federalism and the american healthcare act

Republicans may talk the talk of devolving health care policy to the states, but that’s not what the American Health Care Act does. Instead, it starves health reform of the funding upon which it depends.

Most significantly, Republicans intend to phase out the Medicaid expansion and to impose a hard cap on federal contributions. If a recession forces a state to exceed its cap in a given year, any overruns will come out of its Medicaid payments the following year. With that kind of shortfall, the states will have to make savage Medicaid cuts to make ends meet.

Republicans also want to slash the subsidies that make insurance affordable in the private market. Under the ACA, no one making less than four times the poverty level has to devote more than 10 percent of her income toward private coverage; most pay much less. The American Health Care Act would erase that affordability guarantee and, instead, extend age-based subsidies that would be much too meager for most people to afford coverage.

If federal money is withdrawn, states will be stuck. Because of the countercyclical trap and ERISA, they won’t be able to enact and sustain coverage expansions on their own. The end result will not be the diversity that federalism celebrates. It will be a uniformly crappy system that leaves millions of the sick and poor without coverage.

It doesn’t have to be this way. A group of Republican senators led by Bill Cassidy (R-LA) and Susan Collins (R-ME) has floated an alternative, the Patient Freedom Act of 2017, that retains the ACA’s funding streams while giving the states more room to choose how to use that money. That’s a model that deserves serious attention from both Republicans and Democrats. It might enable partisans on both sides move past the rancorous debate over the ACA.

For now, however, the Republicans seem intent on dismantling coverage gains across the entire United States. Their proposals trade on the rhetoric of states’ rights, but they would have the perverse effect of inhibiting state power. That’s bad for federalism — and bad for the country.

 

Traditional Medicare is cheaper

http://www.academyhealth.org/blog/2017-03/traditional-medicare-cheaper

phys-svcs-pmnt

OK, you knew that already. But what are the implications for access to care?

t probably won’t come as a surprise to you that traditional Medicare (TM) pays lower health care prices than commercial market insurers. We’ve known this for quite some time. A significant issue, however, is whether lower TM rates lead (or could lead) to reduced access to care for Medicare beneficiaries.

Jacob Wallace and Zirui Song took up the issue in a Health Affairs paper published last year. They examined health care price and utilization of outpatient imaging and outpatient surgical procedures across the 65-year divide — when most people become eligible for Medicare. Their data included just over 200,000 individuals captured in Truven Health Analytics’ 2007–2013 Medicare and Commercial Claims and Encounters database with broad-network, commercial market insurance before age 65 and TM from age 65 onward.

As shown in the chart just below, unadjusted, per beneficiary, quarterly spending trends for outpatient imaging and procedures are about the same before and after Medicare eligibility, but there is a large discontinuity when Medicare eligibility begins. In the last quarter before age 65, spending for a privately insured patient is about $119. At age 65, on Medicare, that drops 25% to about $89. After adjusting for age, quarter, year, and individual fixed effects, the relative change upon Medicare eligibility is even larger: 32%.

 

The American Health Care Act: 10 things to know

http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/hospital-management-administration/gop-health-bill-is-out-10-things-to-know-this-morning.html

Image result for american healthcare act

After years of lobbying to repeal and replace the ACA, House Republicans put forth The American Health Care Act on Monday. Here are 10 things to know about the legislation.

1. The AHCA would eliminate the ACA’s individual mandate, or requirement for American adults to enroll in health insurance. Further, the legislation eliminates the tax penalty adults faced if they were not covered. However, the concept of penalties still remains in some form: To encourage people to buy coverage, the AHCA lets insurers charge a 30 percent penalty for those who let their health plans lapse and try to buy a new policy, according to NPR.

2. The AHCA calls for Medicaid expansion to remain in effect through Jan. 1, 2020. This is different from earlier drafts of legislation, which called for an immediate reversal of Medicaid expansion. Thirty-one states, plus Washington, D.C., have opted to expand Medicaid under the ACA. By 2020, the government will “freeze” the expanded programs and restrict funding only to people who were in the program as of then — no added enrollees from that date on. States would keep getting that amount of federal aid for each Medicaid enrollee as long as the enrollee doesn’t lose eligibility for more than a month. There is also a provision in the AHCA that calls for grants of extra Medicaid provider reimbursement funds to go toward states that didn’t expand Medicaid.

3. The AHCA restructures Medicaid’s federal funding to a per-capita cap opposed to the current open-ended federal entitlement, reports Politico. States would receive capped payments based on how many people are enrolled in Medicaid. The plan also calls for more frequent eligibility testing of Medicaid enrollees.

4. The AHCA restructures Americans’ tax credits to buy health insurance. It replaces income-based subsidies under the ACA with refundable, age-based and income-capped tax credits, according to Politico. These credits increase with age, from as low as $2,000 for those under 30 or as high as $4,000 for those over 60. There would be a limit as far as credits for a single household — $14,000 — and subsidies would be eliminated over time for individuals with annual income of $75,000 and for families with annual income of $150,000, according to the report.

5. A few ACA staples roll over in the AHCA. The ACA provision related to pre-existing conditions would remain intact, meaning insurers would not be able to deny coverage or increase prices for people with such conditions, reports Reuters. Also, the AHCA retains provisions allowing adults up to age 26 to maintain coverage through their parents’ health plans, according to the report.

6. The AHCA eliminates the cap on the tax exemption for employer-sponsored insurance. Although earlier drafts of legislation capped the exemption at 90 percent of current premiums, the final version eliminated the proposal, according to Politico. The bill also gets rid of the penalty for businesses that do not offer employees health coverage.

7. The AHCA delays the effective date for the ACA’s Cadillac Tax on costly health plans from 2020 to 2025, according to The Hill. GOP lawmakers are delaying but keeping the tax to make certain their replacement plan will not increase the national deficit after a decade.

8. The AHCA bars federal Medicaid funds or federal family planning grants for Planned Parenthood clinics, according to the report. (Separate from the AHCA, the White House earlier this week extended terms for a compromise to Planned Parenthood by proposing maintained federal funding if the group agrees to discontinue providing abortions, according to ABC News.)

9. The cost of the AHCA is not yet known. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office has not yet scored the legislation, which means there is neither a cost estimate for the plan or how many Americans would gain or lose insurance under it.

10. What’s next? The House Ways and Means and Energy and Commerce committees are expected to review the AHCA legislation Wednesday. If the committees approve the measure, the full House could potentially act on it before April 7, according to The New York Times. The measure would then be taken up by the Senate.

Fitch: Changes to Medicaid in ACA repeal bill pose risks for hospitals

http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/fitch-changes-to-medicaid-in-aca-repeal-bill-pose-risks-for-hospitals.html

Image result for hospital credit ratings

House Republicans’ proposed ACA repeal and replacement plan, known as the American Health Care Act, calls for changes to Medicaid that expose states and hospitals to new fiscal risks, according to a Fitch Ratings report.

The AHCA would eliminate Medicaid’s entitlement structure and restructure the program’s federal funding to a per-capita cap system on Jan. 1, 2020. This change is intended to slow Medicaid spending growth. The Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured estimates switching to a per-capita cap system would reduce federal spending on Medicaid by $1 trillion (or 26 percent) over 10 years. This reduction would require states to make significant budgetary changes and could result in reduced reimbursement for hospitals, according to the report.

The AHCA calls for the government to freeze expanded Medicaid programs on Jan. 1, 2020, and restrict funding only to people who were enrolled in the expanded programs as of Dec. 31, 2019. Under the ACHA, states that expanded Medicaid “will be faced with a unique policy predicament of denying Medicaid access to individuals who would otherwise qualify beginning in 2020, or taking on significant costs they had anticipated would be bored largely by the federal government,” according to Fitch.

Behold the G.O.P. Civil War on Health Care

 

As people began to digest the Republican health care plan on Tuesday, a few things became clear:

1. “This isn’t an Obamacare repeal, it’s a Medicaid repeal,” as the political writer Jonathan Allen put it.

Many Republicans have long viewed Medicaid — a health insurance program for the poor, the disabled and some elderly — with skepticism. This plan would make very large cuts to the program. The details are somewhat technical, and Edwin Park of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities explains them. But the real-world effects will be concrete: Many people will lose coverage, and some kinds of care, if the bill becomes law.

2. Conservative policy experts hate the bill, and the criticisms come from both the far right and the center right.

Peter Suderman of Reason had an excellent frame for understanding the right’s civil war over health care: Conservatives don’t even agree on what their goals are. Making health care less expensive? Reducing the government’s role? Ensuring that the poor receive fewer subsidies?

Lacking this agreement, many Republicans have pretended that a magical health plan exists, one that would cover everyone, provide good insurance and cost less money. Wouldn’t that be nice!

 

House GOP’s Obamacare Replacement Will Make Coverage Unaffordable For Millions — Otherwise, It’s Great

https://www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/2017/03/07/house-gops-obamacare-replacement-will-make-coverage-unaffordable-for-millions-otherwise-its-great/#3540ba3d37fd

Image result for Medicaid

That’s not an ironic headline. Leading House Republicans have included a number of transformative and consequential reforms in their American Health Care Act, the full text of which was published Monday evening. But those reforms are overshadowed by the bill’s stubborn desire to make health insurance unaffordable for millions of Americans, and trap millions more in poverty. Can such a bill garner the near-universal Republican support it will need to pass Congress?