Category Archives: Investment Strategy

Hospital and Health System M&A: Q1 2024 Review

Posted on by • Posted in Divestitures, Federal Trade Commission (FTC), Health System, Hospital, Hospital Industry, Investment Banking, Investment Strategy, Market Consolidation, Market Power, Market Share, Market Trends, Mergers & Acquisitions • Leave a comment

Click to access a311cc93-4ee7-486e-b11a-850e2152a51a.pdf

M&A Volume Up in Q1 2024 vs. Q1 2023: $10 billion Target Revenues


The number of hospital and health system M&A deals announced in the first quarter of 2024 was significantly higher than in the same period in 2023: 18 announced transactions with $10 billion in total revenues for the targets vs. 12 deals in Q1 2023 with a total of $3.4 billion in revenues for the targets. The 81 deals announced in the last 12 months is the highest it
has been over the last few years, building upon the recent momentum of hospital and health system mergers, acquisitions, and divestitures across the country.

Other observations by the Cain Brothers M&A team:

  • Significant number of for-profit conversions to not-for-profit (e.g., divestitures by Tenet and HCA)
  • Significant number of divestitures by national systems to regional health systems
  • Accelerated closing timeline for 3 deals in CA: closed in 30-60 days — prior to new hospital merger review process going into effect April 1, 2024 in CA
  • Q1 2024 total volume of 18 transactions with $10 billion in revenues for targets vs. $3.4 billion for Q1 2023
    This quarter saw transformative deals that may reshape how healthcare is delivered, reflecting creative partnerships that continue to form in a changing healthcare environment. Academic medical centers continue to make investments in assets
    of high strategic value to expand their clinical, teaching, and research capabilities. Large regional systems were quite active, with large cross regional mergers and smaller strategic acquisitions. With the Consumer Price Index (CPI) holding steady with the previous quarter, alleviation of supply cost pressures will benefit health system financials and allow them to deploy more capital.

In early January, General Catalyst’s healthcare investment subsidiary, Health
Assurance Transformation Corporation (“HATCo”), announced its intent to
acquire Summa Health, one of the largest integrated health delivery systems in
Ohio. This announcement made waves in the healthcare industry, not just
because of the size of the acquisition, but because it is the first major health system
investment for newly formed HATCo. General Catalyst, a venture capital firm
formed in 2000, is known for its investments in global companies including Airbnb,
Warby Parker, Snap, and Kayak. General Catalyst launched HATCo in October
2023 as a vehicle to enable health systems to enhance technological health
capabilities, improve financial results, and assist in meeting the shift to value based care, creating a sustainable and quality-driven healthcare model for providers and patients.

Under the terms of the deal, Summa Health will become a subsidiary of HATCo
and transition from a not-for-profit to a for-profit corporation. A community
foundation will be formed to continue to invest in the social determinants of health
to enhance community outcomes in the Akron-Canton region. With its first
acquisition, HATCo aims to become a chassis for future acquisitions and growth
for General Catalyst. The deal is expected to close by the end of 2024.

Academic medical centers were active acquirers in the first quarter of 2024. On
the West Coast, two University of California systems announced acquisitions from
for-profit operators. In January, UCLA Health announced it is the process to
acquire West Hills Hospital and Medical Center from HCA. The 260-bed hospital
is located in the San Fernando Valley, north of Los Angeles, and will be UCLA’s
first acute care hospital in the area. In February, UC Irvine Health signed a
definitive agreement to acquire Tenet’s Pacific Coast Network, which include
four hospitals in Los Angeles and Orange counties (see below for transaction
multiples). The acquisition greatly expands UCI Health’s presence and inpatient
bed capacity to complement their flagship UCI Medical Center in Orange. These
deals come off the heels of two other University of California deals announced in
2023; UC San Diego Health’s acquisition of Alvarado Hospital from Prime
Healthcare, and UCSF’s announcement to acquire two San Francisco hospitals
from Dignity Health, further demonstrating the UC system’s mandate to grow and
provide greater access to care in California.


Further east, the University of Minnesota announced in February its intent to
reacquire the University of Minnesota Medical Center from Fairview Health.
The University of Minnesota Regents voted to support a nonbinding letter of intent
with Fairview that would provide the ability for the University’s eventual ownership
of the medical center by 2027. The University of Minnesota previously sold the
medical center to Fairview in 1997.


In January, Penn Medicine announced it intends to acquire Doylestown Health,
a single-hospital system in Bucks County, PA. The seventh hospital for Penn
Medicine, the acquisition of Doylestown Health follows a trend of expansion for
Penn Medicine, with the acquisition of Chester County Hospital, Lancaster General
Health, and Princeton Health all within the past 10 years. The transactions by
academic health systems this quarter continue to follow the trend of AMC
expansion through development of new entry points into their care network,
investments in community health, and developing the ability to expand their
teaching and research capabilities.

In addition to the sale of its Pacific Coast Network to UC Irvine Health, Tenet also
sold Sierra Vista Regional Medical Center and Twin Cities Community
Hospital to Adventist Health in California. The two hospitals, located in San Luis
Obispo County in Central California, were sold to Adventist Health for
approximately $550 million, implying a Revenue and EBITDA multiple of 1.6x and
14.5x, respectively. The Pacific Coast Network transaction to UCI Health
announced in February came with a $975 million price tag, reflecting a 1.0x
multiple of revenue and 13.7x multiple of EBITDA. These transactions follow trends
of Tenet’s strategic divestitures in high value deals and reflect a broader trend of
acquisitions of targets of high strategic value to health systems. It is worth noting
that part of the reason for higher multiples in these California transactions is that
buying is still cheaper than the high cost to build.


Regional expansion continued this quarter in the Northeast with Nuvance Health’s
announcement in February that it will be joining Northwell Health. With seven
hospitals in Nuvance and the largest in the State of New York with Northwell, the
organizations would merge to form an integrated healthcare delivery system of 28
hospitals, 15,000 physicians, and over 1,000 care sites. In July 2023, Nuvance
received a credit downgrade from Moody’s driven by weakened operating
performance and reduced liquidity. As stated by both organizations, the merger
also allows Northwell to expand into Connecticut while making significant
investments in Nuvance’s existing clinical care footprint.


On the other hand, a number of regional mergers in recent years have been called
off, including this quarter with the cancellation of the proposed merger between
Essential Health and Marshfield Clinic. Previously announced in July 2023, the
health systems formally ended merger discussions in January, determining that
the affiliation was not the right path for the organizations. Marshfield previously
paused merger discussions with Gundersen Health System in 2019.

There were also a number of single hospital acquisitions and tuck-in transactions for larger systems. Below are highlights of a few other notable transactions announced this quarter:

In February, St. Louis- based Mercy announced its plans to acquire Via Christi Hospital, its
related physicians and other ancillary healthcare locations from Ascension. 152-bed Via Christi
hospital will be Mercy’s third hospital in Kansas, as Mercy continues to grow westward. In 2023,
Mercy acquired SoutheastHEALTH followed by its acquisition of Hermann Area District Hospital.

In January, Northern New Jersey health systems, CarePoint Health and Hudson Regional
Hospital announced they are seeking to form a new combined entity that will merge the for-profit and not-for-profit hospitals together. Hudson Health System will be the new namesake of the four hospital system. Under the proposed agreement, two of the four hospitals will remain not-for-profit safety net hospitals. The unique arrangement comes after the New Jersey Department of Health confirmed that CarePoint was in financial distress and began to work with local government leaders on a solution. CarePoint executive leaders confirmed the arrangement with Hudson Regional will improve the organization’s operational and financial strength.

Also in New Jersey, Atlantic Health System announced in January its intent to merge with Saint
Peter’s Healthcare. Atlantic Health, located in Morristown, NJ, is a seven-hospital health system
with locations across New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Saint Peter’s Healthcare is a catholic not-forprofit system with a 478-bed flagship hospital in New Brunswick, NJ. The announcement follows a 2022 judgment by the FTC to block a proposed merger between Saint Peter’s Healthcare and RWJBarnabas Health, citing the deal would cause anti-competitive concerns with merging New Brunswick’s only two hospitals.

WellSpan Health signed a definitive agreement to acquire Evangelical Community Hospital, a
131-bed acute care hospital in Lewisburg, PA. With the pending acquisition, the hospital will
become WellSpan Evangelical Hospital and will continue to serve the Central Susquehanna Valley. WellSpan is an eight-hospital system, serving six counties in Pennsylvania and two counties in Maryland. The deal is expected to close in July.

Each quarter, health system acquirers typically cite the need to grow and the desire to enchance clinical outcomes as motivating factors for deal activity. On the other hand, as we are seeing play out in real time, financial challenges area key driver of M&A for sellers. California-based Pipeline Health faces financial challenges as it retrenches its existing portfolio. In late 2023, Pipeline exited the Texas market driven by unsustainable financial losses. This example highlights the need for health systems to match mission-driven growth objectives with the reality of a harsh and volitile operating environment.


Portfolio rationalization, AMCs with the capital to make big bets, and inter-regional consolidations are major trends that will continue into 2024. With an election looming and an uncertain healthcare and regulatory landscape, affiliation opportunities will need to be thoughtful and metric driven.

Tenet, HCA, Optum compete for market share in emerging battleground

Posted on by • Posted in Ambulatory Surgery Centers (ASC), Competition, For-Profit, Investment Strategy, Investments, Investor Owned, Outpatient Care, Outpatient Medical Management, Outpatient Migration, Outpatient Surgery, Private Equity, Strategic Attention, Strategic Resource Allocation, Strategic Target Monitoring, Strategy, Strategy National • Leave a comment
https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/tenet-hca-optum-compete-for-market-share-of-emerging-battleground.html?utm_medium=email&utm_content=newsletter

Health systems are ramping up investments in ambulatory surgery centers and forming joint ventures with outpatient partners to accelerate the development of new centers. The trend is picking up steam as complex procedures increasingly move to ASCs, which are steadily growing as the preferred site of service for physicians, patients and payers. 

Tenet Healthcare, one of the largest for-profit health systems in the country, has been paying close attention to outpatient migration for years and has cemented itself as the leader in the ASC space. It now operates more than 445 ASCs — the most of any health system — and 24 surgical hospitals, according to its first-quarter earnings report. 

United Surgical Partners International, Tenet’s ASC company, strengthened its footing in the ASC market after its $1.2 billion acquisition of Towson, Md.-based SurgCenter Development and its more than 90 ASCs in December 2021. Over the next several years, USPI will inject more than $250 million into ASC mergers and acquisitions and work with SurgCenter to develop at least 50 more ASCs, according to terms of the transaction. 

The SurgCenter acquisition was completed shortly after Tenet sold five Florida hospitals to Dallas-based Steward Health Care for $1.1 billion. In 2022, Tenet also acquired Dallas-based Baylor Scott & White Health’s 5 percent equity position in USPI to own 100 percent of the company’s voting shares and paid $78 million to acquire ownership of eight Compass Surgical Partners ASCs.

These ASC investments and hospital sales make it clear that CEO Saum Sutaria, MD, sees surgery centers to become Tenet’s main growth driver in the coming years. Dr. Sutaria has described USPI as the company’s “gem for the future,” and aims to have 575 to 600 ASCs by the end of 2025.

While Tenet continues to increase its ASC market share, its closest competitor is Deerfield, Ill.-based SCA Health, which UnitedHealth Group’s Optum acquired for $2.3 billion several years ago. 

SCA has more than 320 ASCs, but has expanded its focus on value-based care under Optum and is doubling down on supporting physicians across the specialty care continuum rather than operating as an ASC company “singularly focused on partnering with surgeons in their ASCs,” SCA CEO Caitlin Zulla told Becker’s.

While Tenet may operate the most ASCs among health systems, it lags behind Optum in terms of the number of physicians it employs. Optum is now affiliated with more than 70,000 physicians, making it the largest employer of physicians in the country, and is continuing to add to that through mergers and acquisitions.

Nashville, Tenn.-based HCA Healthcare, another for-profit system, employs or is affiliated with more than 47,000 physicians, but is also ramping up its surgery center portfolio. HCA comprises 2,300 ambulatory care facilities, including more than 150 ASCs, freestanding emergency rooms, urgent care centers and physician clinics, according to its first-quarter earnings report. 

Like Tenet and Optum, HCA is heavily focused on expanding its outpatient portfolio. The company ended 2021 with 125 ASCs, four more than it had at the end of 2020, and added more than 25 ASCs last year. It is focused on both developing and acquiring surgery centers in the coming years. 

The other big ASC operators include Nashville, Tenn.-based AmSurg, with more than 250 surgery centers, and Brentwood, Tenn.-based Surgery Partners, with more than 120 centers. Surgery Partners spent about $250 million on ASCs acquisitions last year and recently signed collaboration agreements with two large health systems —- Salt Lake City-based Intermountain Health and Columbus-based OhioHealth. 

Oakland, Calif.-based Kaiser Permanente has 62 freestanding ASCs and outpatient surgery departments on its hospital campuses, a spokesperson for the health system told Becker’s. 

Investment gains masking health system operating margin difficulties 

Posted on by • Posted in Consumer-Centered Care Pathway, Consumer-Centric, Consumerism, Health System, Hospital, Hospital Industry, Investing, Investment Strategy, Investments, Key Performance Indicators, Labor Spend Management, Legacy Business Model, Net Income, Non-Profit Healthcare Industry, Nonoperating Income, Operating Expense Reduction, Operating Expenses, Operating Income, Operating Margin, Operating Metrics, Operating Performance, Operating Revenue, Revenue Diversification, Strategy Sustainable Long Term • Leave a comment
https://us17.campaign-archive.com/?e=d1e747d2d8&u=526c5e99ee0439b6f83f7c051&id=1e04d9dbd7

The combination of the Omicron surge, lackluster volume recovery, and rising expenses have contributed to a poor financial start of the year for most health systems. The graphic above shows that, after a healthier-than-expected 2021, the average hospital’s operating margin fell back into the red in early 2022, clocking in more than four percent lower than pre-pandemic levels. 

Despite operational challenges, however, many of the largest health systems continue to garner headlines for their sizable profits, thanks to significant returns on their investment portfolios in 2021.

While CommonSpirit and Providence each posted negative operating margins for the second half of 2021, and Ascension managed a small operating profit, all three were able to use investment income to cushion their performance.

A growing number of health systems are doubling down on investment strategies in an effort to diversify revenue streams, and capture the kind of returns from investments generated by venture capital firms. However, it is unlikely that revenue diversification will be a sustainable long-term strategy.

To succeed, health systems must look to reconfigure elements of the legacy business model that are proving financially unsustainable amid rising expenses, shifts of care to lower-cost settings, and an evolving, consumer-centric landscape.